- Research article
- Open Access
High dietary quality of non-toxic cyanobacteria for a benthic grazer and its implications for the control of cyanobacterial biofilms
BMC Ecology volume 17, Article number: 20 (2017)
Mass occurrences of cyanobacteria frequently cause detrimental effects to the functioning of aquatic ecosystems. Consequently, attempts haven been made to control cyanobacterial blooms through naturally co-occurring herbivores. Control of cyanobacteria through herbivores often appears to be constrained by their low dietary quality, rather than by the possession of toxins, as also non-toxic cyanobacteria are hardly consumed by many herbivores. It was thus hypothesized that the consumption of non-toxic cyanobacteria may be improved when complemented with other high quality prey. We conducted a laboratory experiment in which we fed the herbivorous freshwater gastropod Lymnaea stagnalis single non-toxic cyanobacterial and unialgal diets or a mixed diet to test if diet-mixing may enable these herbivores to control non-toxic cyanobacterial mass abundances.
The treatments where L. stagnalis were fed non-toxic cyanobacteria and a mixed diet provided a significantly higher shell and soft-body growth rate than the average of all single algal, but not the non-toxic cyanobacterial diets. However, the increase in growth provided by the non-toxic cyanobacteria diets could not be related to typical determinants of dietary quality such as toxicity, nutrient stoichiometry or essential fatty acid content.
These results strongly contradict previous research which describes non-toxic cyanobacteria as a low quality food resource for freshwater herbivores in general. Our findings thus have strong implications to gastropod-cyanobacteria relationships and suggest that freshwater gastropods may be able to control mass occurrences of benthic non-toxic cyanobacteria, frequently observed in eutrophied water bodies worldwide.
Cyanobacteria are a common component in the diets of herbivores in freshwater ecosystems. Cyanobacteria often occur in eutrophied water bodies and represent a low-quality food source for consumer species caused by a variety of factors such as the possession of toxins [1, 2], feeding inhibitors , unsuitable morphology  and the lack of essential dietary lipids . In particular, their low amounts of the essential polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFA) omega 3 and omega 6  and sterols, strongly constrain the fitness of herbivores on cyanobacterial diets [4, 6]. Within a cyanobacterial species, individual strains can be toxic or non-toxic. Although less frequently studied, non-toxic cyanobacteria are known to reduce growth  and reproduction , at a similar magnitude as toxin-bearing cyanobacteria, to cladocerans and copepods. Surveys conducted in different parts of the world showed that up to 75% of cyanobacterial blooms can be non-toxic [9,10,11]. Non-toxic cyanobacteria may consequently impact ecosystems, trophic cascades and geochemical cycles . Interestingly, in a meta-analysis by Wilson et al. , it was found that cyanobacterial toxins were actually less important with respect to their negative effects on consumer fitness than cyanobacterial cell morphology. Wilson et al.  therefore concluded that the role of cyanobacterial toxins in the determination of food quality may be less important than widely assumed and suggested that future research should focus more on nutritional deficiencies, morphology, and the toxicity of undescribed cyanobacterial compounds as mediators of the poor food quality of cyanobacteria.
Due to the multiple threats that cyanobacteria may pose to ecosystems, various attempts have been made to control cyanobacterial mass abundances (‘blooms’) through herbivory [13, 14]. However, this requires that the herbivores are able to efficiently utilize cyanobacteria as a food resource. While pure cyanobacteria may be a low quality food resource, a mixed diet with cyanobacterial and eukaryotic components may be easier to assimilate for many herbivores. For example, a severe sterol limitation of the planktonic herbivore Daphnia is assumed to occur only if cyanobacteria make up more than 80% of phytoplankton biomass . Moreover, the growth of Dreissena polymorpha was strongly reduced while feeding upon a pure cyanobacterial diet deficient in polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs) in comparison to a mixed diet rich in PUFAs . By consuming a mixed diet, herbivores may obtain all nutrients required for growth. This is called the balanced diet hypothesis [17, 18] and has been described for numerous herbivores for example insects , snails  and fish . Diet mixing may enable grazers to feed upon cyanobacteria without any significant decrease in fitness, and thus reduce cyanobacterial blooms. In a study by DeMott and Müller-Navarra , Daphnia feeding upon non-toxic cyanobacteria did not display any increase in growth, but when supplemented with a green alga a significant increase in growth was observed. Additionally, rotifers were found to grow better on a diet consisting of a mixture between green algae and cyanobacteria than on either single algal diet . Herbivores may also compensate for a low quality diet through compensatory feeding [24,25,26]. This is a strategy in which herbivores increase their consumption rate as dietary nutrient concentrations decrease in order to maintain a sufficient uptake of the limiting nutrient(s). Compensatory feeding may thereby increase the fitness of herbivores, but it may also be associated with costs . With respect to macronutrients, herbivores maintain a rather strict homeostasis [28, 29], for instance they need to maintain their body’s elemental composition by excreting excess nutrients. This requires energy and results in a reduction of fitness [30, 31]. Moreover, when consuming food in higher quantities, the dosage of potential toxins in the diet can increase .
Effects of cyanobacterial diets on freshwater gastropods have rarely been studied. While feeding upon benthic biofilms gastropods rarely only encounter cyanobacteria, but mixtures of various microalgae, bacteria and protozoa embedded in a mucopolysaccharide matrix . Gastropods can represent up to 60% of the total biomass of macroinvertebrates in freshwater ecosystems  and they play a key role in the top-down control of benthic primary production. For instance, Lymnaea stagnalis (L.), is a benthic herbivore  and important grazer in freshwater habitats . It is often found in small eutrophic water bodies  where cyanobacteria are extremely common. It is thus plausible to assume that L. stagnalis has evolved strategies to cope with cyanobacterial presence in its diet. L. stagnalis detects its food via semiochemicals , but prey selection on the level of individual food items (e.g. algal cells) is not possible due to the rather unspecific ingestion mode via the gastropod radula . Moreover, it is a common model organism in experimental ecology [37,38,39].
The aim of this study was to test whether gastropods may be able to feed upon non-toxic cyanobacteria without any significant decrease in fitness through the benefits of diet-mixing. Further, we aimed to investigate which factors are responsible for the typically observed low food quality of non-toxic cyanobacteria to freshwater herbivores [40, 41]. We thus hypothesized (1) that a pure diet consisting of non-toxic cyanobacteria will decrease the fitness of freshwater gastropods, and that (2) diet-mixing allows these gastropods to feed upon non-toxic cyanobacteria without any significant decrease in fitness. To test our hypotheses, we conducted a laboratory experiment using juveniles of the great pond snail L. stagnalis which we fed with either single, non-toxic cyanobacterial and algal diets or a mixture of all (six) primary producer species. The aquatic primary producers chosen for this experiment belonged to the three most important groups of organisms in freshwater biofilms: cyanobacteria, chlorophytes and diatoms.
We randomly selected six species of primary producers, two chlorophytes (Aphanochaete repens and Klebsormidium flaccidum), two cyanobacteria (Cylindrospermum sp. and Lyngbya halophila), and two diatoms (Navicula sp. and Nitzschia communis) from the Culture Collection of Algae at Cologne (CCAC, see Table 1). The size and structure of the primary producer cells were determined by microscopy to test whether the morphology of the cells may impact the fitness of L. stagnalis (Table 1). All six primary producer strains were cultivated under continuous aeration in 8 L of cyanophyceae medium  for cyanobacteria and chlorophytes or in diatom medium  for diatoms, respectively. All cultures were kept in a climatized chamber at 20 ± 1 °C at a light intensity of 150 µmol photons s−1 m−2 as described elsewhere . After one (chlorophytes and cyanobacteria) or two months (for diatoms) of exponential growth, the primary producers were harvested by centrifugation at 4500×g and the resulting pellets were freeze-dried . Juvenile L. stagnalis, originating from a pond in Appeldorn, Germany, were raised in aquaria in a climatized chamber at 18 ± 1 °C with a light–dark period of 16:8 h and fed ad libitum with Tetra Wafer Mix™ fish food pellets (Tetra, Melle, Germany) prior to the experiment .
A total of 64 juvenile L. stagnalis with a shell height (defined as the distance from the apex to the lower edge of the aperture) of 2.0 ± 0.2 mm were selected. Out of these, eight had their shells removed under a dissecting microscope and were subsequently freeze-dried for the determination of their initial soft body dry mass (dm) using a microbalance (Mettler UTM2, Giessen, Germany). The experiment took place in a climatized chamber at 20 ± 1 °C. The snails were individually kept in square polyethylene containers (length = 11 cm) with each 100 ml aged and aerated tap water and fed on a daily basis. The primary producers were rehydrated in 1 ml water each and then added through a hollow glass cylinder (d = 2.3 cm, h = 2.5 cm) that was submerged halfway in the water in the center of the snails’ container. After approximately 1 h when the primary producers had sedimented to the bottom of the container, the glass cylinders were removed. This yielded one clear resource patch and prevented selective feeding by the snails in the mixed primary producer treatment. Water was exchanged daily and the containers were replaced with clean ones every other day. The experiment consisted of seven treatments with eight replicates each, we thus used 56 containers, each containing one L. stagnalis individual. The seven treatments consisted of snails fed with a mixture of all six primary producer species or with one of the six primary producer species. To ensure that the snails could feed ad libitum, the amount of added food was increased during the 33 days experimental duration using previously estimated shell size specific ingestion rates . The shell height of the snails was measured every three days as described above. After 33 days, the soft body dry mass of the remaining 54 snails (single incidents of death had occurred in the treatments with A. repens and K. flaccidum as diet organism during the experiment) was determined as described above. Since the juvenile growth of L. stagnalis can be assumed to be exponential , the somatic growth rate of the snails was estimated using the following equation:
where mstart is the initial dry mass of snails and mend is the dry mass of the snails at the end of the experiment (day 33) over time (d), yielding the somatic growth rate (g).
On the final day of the experiment, the snails’ ingestion rates were determined in the same setup used to determine the somatic growth rates of the snails. Additionally, three control units per dietary treatment were set up without snails. After 19 h, the snails and their fecal pellets were separately removed from the containers and the remaining primary producers were filtered onto pre-combusted glass fiber filters (GF/F, d = 25 mm, VWR GmbH, Darmstadt, Germany) and dried at 60 °C for 24 h. The amount of ingested food was determined by subtracting the primary producer dry mass remaining in the snails’ containers after 19 h from the primary producer dry mass in the consumer-free controls.
To determine the C:N ratios of the primary producers, approximately 1 mg of each freeze-dried primary producer culture, including a mixture of all six primary producers in equal dry mass were packed into tin capsules (HekaTech, Wegberg, Germany) and subsequently analyzed using a Thermo Flash EA 2000 elemental Analyser (Schwerte, Germany). For the analysis of particulate phosphorus, approximately 1 mg of freeze-dried primary producers were transferred into a solution of potassium peroxodisulphate and 1.5% sodium hydroxide. The solution was subsequently autoclaved for 1 h at 120 °C and the soluble reactive phosphorus was analyzed using the molybdate–ascorbic acid method . Both analyses were replicated fivefold per food treatment. The same method was applied to separately determine the molar C:N:P ratios of the 54 snails. When the mass of individual gastropod samples did not reach the required 1 mg dry mass, samples of several individuals from the same treatment were pooled randomly to reach sufficient sample masses.
Fatty acid analysis
Cultures of all primary producers were harvested in the exponential growth phase and filtered in triplicate onto precombusted GF/F filters to assess their fatty acid contents. Filters were placed into 5 mL CH2Cl2/MeOH (2:1 v/v) to extract total lipids. The samples were incubated over night at 4 °C whereafter 10 µg of methyl heptadecanoate (C17:0 ME) and 5 µg methyl tricosanoate (C23:0 ME), were added as internal standards. Subsequently, the samples were homogenized in an ultrasonic bath for 1 min and then centrifuged at 4500×g for 5 min. Afterwards, the supernatants were dried at 40 °C under a gentle stream of nitrogen. Hydrolysis of lipids and subsequent methylation of fatty acids were achieved by adding 5 mL of 3 N methanolic HCl (Supelco) to the sample and then incubating the sample for 20 min at 70 °C to yield fatty acid methyl esters (FAMEs). The FAMEs were extracted using 6 mL isohexane. The hexane phase was again dried at 40 °C under a gentle stream of nitrogen. Finally, all samples were dissolved in 100 µL isohexane. The samples were then subjected to gas chromatographic analyses on a 6890 N GC System (Agilent Technologies, Waldbronn, Germany) equipped with a DB-225 capillary column (30 m, 0.25 mm i.d., 0.25 µm film thickness, J&W Scientific, Folsom, CA, USA) and a flame ionization detector (FID). The conditions of the GC were as follows: injector and FID temperatures were set to 220 °C; the initial oven temperature were 60 °C for 1 min, followed by a 2 min temperature ramp to 180 °C, then the temperature was increased to 200 °C over a time period of 12.9 min followed by a final 20.6 min temperature increase to 220 °C; helium (5.0 purity) with a flow rate of 1.5 ml min was used as carrier gas. FAMEs were identified by comparison of retention times with those of reference compounds and quantified using the internal standard and previously established calibration functions for each individual FAME. For more details we refer the reader to .
The two cyanobacterial species used in the experiment (L. halophila and Cylindrospermum sp.) are known to sometimes contain the toxins cylindrospermopsin and lyngbyatoxin-a. We therefore used high-resolution LC–MS to screen for the cyanobacterial toxins cylindrospermopsin and lyngbyatoxin-a in the cyanobacterial cultures to ensure that the toxins were not produced by the cyanobacterial strains. To screen the two cyanobacteria for the toxins cylindrospermopsin and lyngbyatoxin-a, a crude extract from the freeze-dried samples (500 mg dry mass) of the two cyanobacteria (Cylindrospermum sp. and L. halophila) were prepared using 50 mL of 100% methanol (HPLC Grade, VWR). The extracts were incubated for 1 h on a rotary shaker and subsequently centrifuged at 4500×g for 5 min. The supernatant was then evaporated and the residue dissolved in 5 mL of 100% methanol. Three 5 µL subsamples each were analyzed on an Accela Ultra high pressure liquid chromatography (UPLC) system (Thermo Fisher) coupled with an exactive orbitrap mass spectrometer (Thermo Fisher) with electrospray ionization (ESI) in positive and negative ionization mode. As stationary phase, a Nucleosil C18 column (2 × 125 mm length, pore size 100 Å, particle size 3 μm; Macherey–Nagel, Düren, Germany) was used with a gradient of acetonitrile (ACN) and ultrapure water, each containing 0.05% trifluoroacetic acid (TFA). The column temperature was set to 30 °C and the flow rate to 300 µL/min. The solvent gradient started with 0 min: 38% ACN; 2 min: 40% ACN; 12 min: 50% ACN; 12.5 min: 100% ACN; 15 min: 100% ACN; 15.5 min: 38% ACN; 17 min: 38% ACN. Mass spectrometry was carried out at 1 scan s−1 from 150 to 1500 Da in positive and from 120 to 1500 Da in negative ionization mode, respectively (spray voltage 4.5 kV pos./4.3 kV neg. capillary temperature 325 °C, sheath and aux gas nitrogen set to 40 pos./35 neg. and 15 pos./5 neg. respectively). For the identification of potential cyanobacterial toxins, we used extracted ion chromatograms for the respective specific masses of the different compounds (Cylindrospermopsin pos. 416.12345 Da/neg. 414.10889 Da, Lyngbyatoxin-a pos. 438.31150 Da/neg. 436.29695 Da) granting a maximum mass deviation of 3 parts per million (ppm). Electrospray ionization resulted in adduct ions with one positive/one negative charge for the two compounds. We used the Xcalibur software package (Thermo Fisher) for qualitative analysis.
The gastropods’ shell height increase over time was analysed via repeated measures ANOVA in R (v. 3.3.1) , followed by Bonferroni correction. All other statistical tests were performed in SigmaPlot (v. 11, SysStat). The data were checked for normal distribution using the Shapiro–Wilk’s test and for homoscedasticity using Levene’s test. When the data fulfilled the criteria for a parametric test, one-way ANOVAs was performed followed by Tukey’s HSD. When the data did not fulfil the criteria for an ANOVA, a Kruskal–Wallis test was performed followed by Dunn’s post hoc test. Linear regressions were performed to test for relationships between the algal C:N ratio and the ingestion rate of the snails, the algal C:N ratio and the somatic growth rates of the snails, the molar C:N, C:P, N:P ratios of the algae and the molar C:N, C:P, N:P ratios of the snails, and the biovolume of the algae and the somatic growth rate of the snails. An exponential growth, single, 2 parameter regression was performed to test for the relationship between snail dry mass and shell height.
Lymnaea stagnalis fed the cyanobacteria or a mixed diet grew faster than on any of the pure eukaryotic algae, except for the comparison with K. flaccidum (repeated measures ANOVA, F = 26.6, df = 6, P < 0.001, Fig. 1a). The somatic growth rate of L. stagnalis was significantly higher in the treatments where L. halophila and the mixed treatment was offered compared to the treatments in which L. stagnalis was provided with diatoms (Fig. 1b).
The molar C:N ratio (one-way ANOVA, F = 100.00, df = 6, P < 0.001, Fig. 2a) and the molar C:P ratio (one-way ANOVA, F = 59.16, df = 6, P < 0.001, Fig. 2c) of the cyanobacteria were significantly lower than that of the algae. The N:P ratio of L. halophila were significantly lower than the N:P ratio of A. repens and N. communis (Kruskal–Wallis, H = 31.24, df = 6, P < 0.001, Fig. 2e). The C:N ratios of the snails varied significantly between the diet treatments (one-way ANOVA, F = 14.01, df = 5, P < 0.001, Fig. 2b). L. stagnalis feeding upon L. halophila had a significantly lower C:N ratio compared to all other treatments (Fig. 2b), except for A. repens and N. communis. While C:N ratios were lower in L. stagnalis compared to their diets (Fig. 2a, b), the C:N:P ratios of the snails and their dietary organisms were not significantly correlated (see Additional file 1).
The food consumption of L. stagnalis was significantly higher when offered Navicula sp. compared to the treatment in which the snails fed on Cylindrospermum sp. (Kruskal–Wallis, H = 19.88, df = 6, P = 0.003, Fig. 3). However, no significant differences of the ingestion rates between any other treatments were found (Fig. 3). Moreover, the mean ingestion rate of the snails in each treatment increased linearly with the dietary C:N ratio (y = −0.0241 + (0.00683×), R2 = 0.61, df = 6, P = 0.039, N = 7; Fig. 4a), but the mean somatic growth rate and the dietary C:N ratio did not correlate (linear regression, x = 8.458 − (8.825y), R2 = 0.18, df = 6, P = 0.34, N = 7; Fig. 4b). The mean C:N ratios of the snails in each treatment were lower than the mean C:N ratios of any of the diets (N = 7; Fig. 4c). Additionally, no significant relationships between somatic growth rate and the dietary organisms’ cell sizes were found (see Additional file 2).
The fatty acid concentration of the primary producers differed, A. repens and Cylindrospermum sp. were particularly rich in α-linolenic acid (C 18:3 n − 3) whereas N. communis was rich in eicosapentaenoic acid (C20:5 n − 3, see Additional file 3). A. repens and the cyanobacteria contained the highest absolute amount of palmitic acid (C 16:0, see Additional file 3), while the A. repens and N. communis contained the highest total amounts of fatty acids and PUFAs (see Additional file 4).
We did not detect the cyanobacterial toxin cylindrospermopsin in the cyanobacterium Cylindrospermum sp. nor lyngbyatoxin-a in L. halophila via high-resolution LC–MS.
Contrary to our hypothesis, a mixed diet containing non-toxic cyanobacteria did not provide a higher growth rate for L. stagnalis compared to pure non-toxic cyanobacterial diets. Surprisingly, the single non-toxic cyanobacteria provided growth rates higher than or equal to the diet consisting of mixed pro- and eukaryotic primary producers. Non-toxic cyanobacteria—at least the two strains investigated here—may therefore be considered a high quality resource for L. stagnalis. Negative effects of non-toxic cyanobacteria on the fitness of animals have frequently been reported [7, 8]. However, a screening of cyanobacterial strains demonstrated that some cyanobacterial strains can have a high nutritional value . The importance of the supply ratio or stoichiometry of carbon (C), nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) is well studied, as the balance or imbalance in the molar C:N:P supply ratio has been linked to herbivore growth [50, 51], fecundity [52, 53], developmental times  and survival rates . While nitrogen is mainly needed for protein synthesis , phosphorus is required for the synthesis of phospholipids and nucleic acids . We found that the cyanobacterial species exhibited slightly lower C:N and C:P ratios than the green algae. On the other hand, the overall differences in nutrient stoichiometry between the diet organisms were not particularly pronounced and the nutrient ratios typically below those observed for L. stagnalis, which makes a direct nitrogen or phosphorus limitation of snail growth on the green algal diets unlikely. Furthermore, we did not find a significant correlation between the C:N ratio of the algae and the somatic growth rate of the snails, suggesting that the snails were not nitrogen limited. Also, the C:P ratios and the C:N ratios of the snails and the primary producers did not correlate.
The ingestion rate of the snails increased linearly with the C:N ratio of the primary producers, suggesting that compensatory feeding occurred. However, the somatic growth rate of the snails did not correlate with the C:N ratio of the primary producers. It is possible that compensatory feeding by L. stagnalis decreased a reduction in growth caused by nitrogen limitation in our experiment. In a previous study, it was found that the freshwater snail Radix ovata displayed compensatory feeding on low nutrient diets . This dampened the differences in fitness compared to the treatments in which R. ovata was fed a nutrient-rich diet.
The lack of essential fatty acids and sterols in cyanobacteria is frequently held responsible for the reduction in growth of pelagic herbivorous zooplankton [4, 15], but also of filter-feeding clams Corbicula  and mussels Dreissena . Even though the diatom diets in our experiment contained much more PUFAs than the cyanobacteria, L. stagnalis grew better on both cyanobacteria compared to any of the diatoms. This supports previous findings that lymnaeid gastropods appear to be less susceptible to dietary PUFA limitations than other freshwater invertebrates .
Difference in morphology [1, 57, 58] and cell size  can strongly influence the ingestion of algae and cyanobacteria by herbivores. We found that snails feeding upon two filamentous cyanobacterial species grew best. Similar results have been found for the lymnaeid species Radix peregra which ingests filamentous green algae better than diatoms . Grazing by Lymnaea elodes for instance increased the abundance of small coccoid cells of green algae and cyanobacteria at the expense of larger diatoms , suggesting a preference for larger algal cells. However, we could not find any clear correlation between algal cell size and the somatic growth rate of L. stagnalis in this study.
If the fitness of L. stagnalis is increased by the consumption of non-toxic cyanobacteria rather than green algae and diatoms, L. stagnalis might have the ability to decrease non-toxic cyanobacterial abundances. In fact, it has been found that snails have the potential to reduce cyanobacterial blooms. In a study by Armitage and Fong , primary producers were subjected to nutrient enrichment which led to an increase in cyanobacterial blooms by up to 200%. When snails were allowed to feed upon the primary producers only cyanobacteria decreased in biomass . The snails did not avoid consumption of the toxic cyanobacteria, which indicated that they perceived the cyanobacteria as a suitable food resource, even though cyanobacteria could be linked to an increased mortality of the snails . Toxic cyanobacteria are likely to influence competitive interactions by consumer species favoring the most tolerant ones . Previous studies found that crustacean zooplankton of the genus Daphnia are able to locally adapt to environments where cyanobacteria occur in high abundances [62,63,64]. Similarly physical adaptations in freshwater mussels to cyanobacterial toxins have been found . As L. stagnalis often occur in eutrophicated water bodies , habitats where cyanobacteria are known to occur, it is possible that—similar to zooplankton and mussels—Lymnaea have evolved to coexist with cyanobacteria.
We feed L. stagnalis with single primary producer species or a mixture of all species. Due to time constraints we did not investigate the effects of all diet combinations possible on the fitness of L. stagnalis, however, the experimental set-up still it provided insights into gastropod-cyanobacteria relationships.
Efforts have been made in order to control cyanobacterial abundances by manipulating the biomass of herbivores and thereby increasing the top–down grazing pressure on cyanobacteria. However, most studies conducted used toxic cyanobacterial species; therefore, the knowledge of non-toxic cyanobacteria-grazer relationships remains limited. We hypothesized that the growth rate of L. stagnalis should be significantly reduced when feeding upon non-toxic cyanobacteria, we found however, the opposite pattern. Non-toxic cyanobacteria and the mixed diet provided the best growth rates for the snails. L. stagnalis might thus be a good biological control agent for non-toxic cyanobacterial mass occurrences. These results hence have considerable repercussions to how the dietary quality of non-toxic cyanobacteria for gastropods is perceived.
Wilson AE, Sarnelle O, Tillmanns AR. Effects of cyanobacterial toxicity and morphology on the population growth of freshwater zooplankton: meta-analyses of laboratory experiments. Limnol Oceanogr. 2006;51(4):1915–24.
Carmichael WW. Health effects of toxin-producing cyanobacteria: “The CyanoHABs”. Hum Ecol Risk Assess. 2001;7(5):1393–407.
Schwarzenberger A, Zitt A, Kroth P, Mueller S, Von Elert E. Gene expression and activity of digestive proteases in Daphnia: effects of cyanobacterial protease inhibitors. BMC Physiol. 2010;10:6.
Martin-Creuzburg D, von Elert E. Good food versus bad food: the role of sterols and polyunsaturated fatty acids in determining growth and reproduction of Daphnia magna. Aquat Ecol. 2009;43(4):943–50.
Sargent J, Bell J, Bell M, Henderson R, Tocher D. Requirement criteria for essential fatty acids. J Appl Ichthyol. 1995;11(3–4):183–98.
Wacker A, Becher P, von Elert E. Food quality effects of unsaturated fatty acids on larvae of the zebra mussel Dreissena polymorpha. Limnol Oceanogr. 2002;47(4):1242–8.
FerrÃo-Filho AS, Azevedo SM, DeMott WR. Effects of toxic and non-toxic cyanobacteria on the life history of tropical and temperate cladocerans. Freshw Biol. 2000;45(1):1–19.
Koski M, Engström J, Viitasalo M. Reproduction and survival of the calanoid copepod Eurytemora affinis fed with toxic and non-toxic cyanobacteria. Mar Ecol Prog Ser. 1999;186:187–97.
Lindholm T, Vesterkvist P, Spoof L, Lundberg-Niinistö C, Meriluoto J. Microcystin occurrence in lakes in Åland, SW Finland. Hydrobiologia. 2003;505(1):129–38.
Sivonen K. Cyanobacterial toxins and toxin production. Phycologia. 1996;35(6S):12–24.
Vezie C, Brient L, Sivonen K, Bertru G, Lefeuvre JC, Salkinoja-Salonen M. Variation of microcystin content of cyanobacterial blooms and isolated strains in Lake Grand-Lieu (France). Microb Ecol. 1998;35(2):126–35.
Sukenik A, Quesada A, Salmaso N. Global expansion of toxic and non-toxic cyanobacteria: effect on ecosystem functioning. Biodivers Conserv. 2015;24(4):889–908.
Xie P, Liu J. Practical success of biomanipulation using filter-feeding fish to control cyanobacteria blooms: a synthesis of decades of research and application in a subtropical hypereutrophic lake. Sci World J. 2001;1:337–56.
Matveev V, Matveeva L, Jones GJ. Study of the ability of Daphnia carinata King to control phytoplankton and resist cyanobacterial toxicity: implications for biomanipulation in Australia. Mar Freshw Res. 1994;45(5):889–904.
von Elert E, Martin-Creuzburg D, Le Coz JR. Absence of sterols constrains carbon transfer between cyanobacteria and a freshwater herbivore (Daphnia galeata). Proc R Soc Lond B: Biol Sci. 2003;270(1520):1209–14.
Wacker A, von Elert E. Strong influences of larval diet history on subsequent post–settlement growth in the freshwater mollusc Dreissena polymorpha. Proc R Soc Lond B: Biol Sci. 2002;269(1505):2113–9.
Pulliam HR. Diet optimization with nutrient constraints. Am Nat. 1975;109(970):765–8.
Westoby M. What are the biological bases of varied diets? Am Nat. 1978;112(985):627–31.
Unsicker SB, Oswald A, Koehler G, Weisser WW. Complementarity effects through dietary mixing enhance the performance of a generalist insect herbivore. Oecologia. 2008;156(2):313–24.
Watanabe JM. Food preference, food quality and diets of three herbivorous gastropods (Trochidae: Tegula) in a temperate kelp forest habitat. Oecologia. 1984;62(1):47–52.
Lobel PS, Ogden JC. Foraging by the herbivorous parrotfish Sparisoma radians. Mar Biol. 1981;64(2):173–83.
DeMott W, Müller-Navarra D. The importance of highly unsaturated fatty acids in zooplankton nutrition: evidence from experiments with Daphnia, a cyanobacterium and lipid emulsions. Freshw Biol. 1997;38(3):649–64.
Alva-Martínez AF, Fernández R, Sarma S, Nandini S. Effect of mixed toxic diets (Microcystis and Chlorella) on the rotifers Brachionus calyciflorus and Brachionus havanaensis cultured alone and together. Limnol-Ecol Manag Inland Waters. 2009;39(4):302–5.
Fink P, Von Elert E. Physiological responses to stoichiometric constraints: nutrient limitation and compensatory feeding in a freshwater snail. Oikos. 2006;115(3):484–94.
Cruz-Rivera E, Hay ME. Can quantity replace quality? Food choice, compensatory feeding, and fitness of marine mesograzers. Ecology. 2000;81(1):201–19.
Berner D, Blanckenhorn WU, Körner C. Grasshoppers cope with low host plant quality by compensatory feeding and food selection: N limitation challenged. Oikos. 2005;111(3):525–33.
Zehnder CB, Hunter MD. More is not necessarily better: the impact of limiting and excessive nutrients on herbivore population growth rates. Ecol Entomol. 2009;34(4):535–43.
Persson J, Fink P, Goto A, Hood JM, Jonas J, Kato S. To be or not to be what you eat: regulation of stoichiometric homeostasis among autotrophs and heterotrophs. Oikos. 2010;119(5):741–51.
Sterner RW, Elser JJ. Ecological stoichiometry: the biology of elements from molecules to the biosphere. Princeton: Princeton University Press; 2002.
Darchambeau F, Faerøvig PJ, Hessen DO. How Daphnia copes with excess carbon in its food. Oecologia. 2003;136(3):336–46.
Suzuki-Ohno Y, Kawata M, Urabe J. Optimal feeding under stoichiometric constraints: a model of compensatory feeding with functional response. Oikos. 2012;121(4):569–78.
Slansky F, Wheeler G. Caterpillars’ compensatory feeding response to diluted nutrients leads to toxic allelochemical dose. Entomol Exp Appl. 1992;65(2):171–86.
Anderson M. Variations in biofilms colonizing artificial surfaces: seasonal effects and effects of grazers. J Mar Biol Assoc UK. 1995;75(03):705–14.
Habdija I, Lajtner J, Belinic I. The contribution of gastropod biomass in macrobenthic communities of a karstic river. Int Rev Gesamt Hydrobiol. 1995;80(1):103–10.
Dillon R. The ecology of freshwater molluscs, vol. 1. 1st ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; 2000.
Clarke AH. Gastropods as indicators of trophic lake stages. Nautilus. 1979;94:4.
Moelzner J, Fink P. The smell of good food: volatile infochemicals as resource quality indicators. J Anim Ecol. 2014;83(5):1007–14.
Bakker ES, Dobrescu I, Straile D, Holmgren M. Testing the stress gradient hypothesis in herbivore communities: facilitation peaks at intermediate nutrient levels. Ecology. 2013;94(8):1776–84.
Dalesman S, Rundle SD, Bilton DT, Cotton PA. Phylogenetic relatedness and ecological interactions determine antipredator behavior. Ecology. 2007;88(10):2462–7.
Basen T, Martin-Creuzburg D, Rothhaupt KO. Role of essential lipids in determining food quality for the invasive freshwater clam Corbicula fluminea. J N Am Benthol Soc. 2011;30(3):653–64.
von Elert E. Determination of limiting polyunsaturated fatty acids in Daphnia galeata using a new method to enrich food algae with single fatty acids. Limnol Oceanogr. 2002;47(6):1764–73.
von Elert E, Jüttner F. Phosphorus limitation and not light controls the extracellular release of allelopathic compounds by Trichormus doliolum (cyanobacteria). Limnol Oceanogr. 1997;42(8):1796–802.
Wendel T. Lipoxygenase-katalysierte VOC-Bildung: Untersuchungen an Seewasser und Laborkulturen von Diatomeen. Shaker; 1994.
Groendahl S, Fink P. The effect of diet mixing on a nonselective herbivore. PLoS ONE. 2016;11(7):e0158924.
Hillebrand H, Dürselen CD, Kirschtel D, Pollingher U, Zohary T. Biovolume calculation for pelagic and benthic microalgae. J Phycol. 1999;35(2):403–24.
Greenberg A, Trussel R, Clesceri L. Standard method for the examination of water and wastewater. Washington: American Public Health Association (APHA); 1985.
Fink P. Invasion of quality: high amounts of essential fatty acids in the invasive Ponto-Caspian mysid Limnomysis benedeni. J Plankton Res. 2013: fbt029.
Team RC. R: a language and environment for statistical computing. Vienna; 2013.
Becker E, Venkataraman L. Production and utilization of the blue-green alga Spirulina in India. Biomass. 1984;4(2):105–25.
Hessen DO. Nutrient element limitation of zooplankton production. Am Nat. 1992;149:799–814.
Elser JJ, Fagan WF, Denno RF, Dobberfuhl DR, Folarin A, Huberty A, Interlandi S, Kilham SS, McCauley E, Schulz KL, et al. Nutritional constraints in terrestrial and freshwater food webs. Nature. 2000;408(6812):578–80.
Huberty AF, Denno RF. Consequences of nitrogen and phosphorus limitation for the performance of two planthoppers with divergent life-history strategies. Oecologia. 2006;149(3):444–55.
Kilham S, Kreeger D, Goulden C, Lynn S. Effects of algal food quality on fecundity and population growth rates of Daphnia. Freshw Biol. 1997;38(3):639–47.
Weider LJ, Elser JJ, Crease TJ, Mateos M, Cotner JB, Markow TA. The functional significance of ribosomal (r) DNA variation: impacts on the evolutionary ecology of organisms. Annu Rev Ecol Evol Syst. 2005;36:219–42.
Wacker A, Von Elert E. Food quality controls reproduction of the zebra mussel (Dreissena polymorpha). Oecologia. 2003;135(3):332–8.
Fink P. Food quality and food choice in freshwater gastropods: field and laboratory investigations on a key component of littoral food webs. Berlin: Logos-Verlag; 2006.
Lodge D. Selective grazing on periphyton: a determinant of freshwater gastropod microdistributions. Freshw Biol. 1986;16(6):831–41.
Calow P. Studies on the natural diet of Lymnaea pereger obtusa (Kobelt) and its possible ecological implications. J Molluscan Stud. 1970;39(2–3):203–15.
Cuker B. E m: Grazing and nutrient interactions in controlling the activity and composition of the epilithic algal community of an arctic lake. Limnol Oceanogr. 1983;28(1):133–41.
Armitage AR, Fong P. Upward cascading effects of nutrients: shifts in a benthic microalgal community and a negative herbivore response. Oecologia. 2004;139(4):560–7.
Gerard C, Poullain V, Lance E, Acou A, Brient L, Carpentier A. Influence of toxic cyanobacteria on community structure and microcystin accumulation of freshwater molluscs. Environ Pollut. 2009;157(2):609–17.
Schwarzenberger A, D’Hondt S, Vyverman W, von Elert E. Seasonal succession of cyanobacterial protease inhibitors and Daphnia magna genotypes in a eutrophic Swedish lake. Aquat Sci. 2013;75(3):433–45.
Gustafsson S, Rengefors K, Hansson L-A. Increased consumer fitness following transfer of toxin tolerance to offspring via maternal effects. Ecology. 2005;86(10):2561–7.
Hairston N Jr, Holtmeier C, Lampert W, Weider L, Post D, Fischer J, Caceres C, Fox J, Gaedke U. Natural selection for grazer resistance to toxic cyanobacteria: evolution of phenotypic plasticity? Evolution. 2001;55(11):2203–14.
Burmester V, Nimptsch J, Wiegand C. Adaptation of freshwater mussels to cyanobacterial toxins: Response of the biotransformation and antioxidant enzymes. Ecotoxicol Environ Saf. 2012;78:296–309.
SG and PF designed the research. SG conducted the laboratory work, performed the statistical analyses and drafted the manuscript. PF contributed to manuscript writing. Both authors read and approved the final manuscript.
We thank Sofia Albrecht for help with the experiment, Barbara Melkonian at the Culture Collection of Algae at the University of Cologne (CCAC) for providing us with the cyanobacterial and algal cultures, Katja Preuss for assistance with the GC analysis of fatty acids and Christian Burberg for help with the LC–MS screening for cyanobacterial toxins.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Availability of data and materials
The datasets analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.
We confirm that we comply to the guidelines for the use of animal behavior for research and teaching (Animal Behaviour 2012. 83: 301–309).
This study was supported by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG), Grant FI 1548/5-1 to PF.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Additional file 1. Relationship between the C:N:P ratios (mean ± SE) of the primary producers and L. stagnalis. Nonsignificant linear regressions for C:N (A, y = 3.006 + (0.335 x), R2 = 0.27, df = 6, P = 0.23), C:P (B, y = 134.678 - (0.0388 x), R2 < 0.005, df = 6, P = 0.90), and N:P (C, y = 27.849 - (0.342 x), R2 = 0.26, df = 6, P = 0.25).
Additional file 2. Relationship between primary producer biovolume and somatic growth rate of L. stagnalis. Not statistically significant linear regression, y = 0.176 - (0.0000260 x), R2 = 0.63, df = 5, P = 0.06.
Additional file 3. A table of the fatty acid composition of the primary producers used as a food resource for L. stagnalis. Values given are means ± 1 SE of N = 3 replicates analyzed via gas chromatography of fatty acid methyl esters (n.d. = not detected), the standard errors are given in parentheses.
Additional file 4. Total fatty acid and polyunsaturated fatty acid (PUFA) concentration of the primary producers. Values given are means ± 1 SE of N = 3 replicates analyzed via gas chromatography of fatty acid methyl esters, the standard errors are given in parentheses.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.
About this article
Cite this article
Groendahl, S., Fink, P. High dietary quality of non-toxic cyanobacteria for a benthic grazer and its implications for the control of cyanobacterial biofilms. BMC Ecol 17, 20 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12898-017-0130-3
- Balanced diet hypothesis
- Compensatory feeding
- Benthic algae
- Lymnaea stagnalis
- Fatty acids